AES: ESL 382: Computer Applications

Each pair of students should print out two copies of their Web page for the reviewers. Number the lines in the essays from the beginning to the end of the Web page.

Names of Reviewers:

Title and Author of Essay 1:

Title and Author of Essay 2:

Title of Comparison/Contrast Essay:

Content:

1. Look at the titles of the essays. Do they interest the reader and encourage him to read the essay?
   Suggestions:

   
   
   

2. Do the introductions to the essays contain a thesis? --- does the reader know what the essay will be about after reading the introduction?
   Suggestions:

    

    

3. Are the essays easy to follow? Are the sentences and paragraphs in correct order?
   Suggestions:

    

    

4. Put a "?" next to any parts of the essays which are not clear to you.
   
5. Write "more" next to any part of the essays which need more detail.

Links:

1. How many links to other Web pages are on the page?
   
2. Do the links improve the content of the Web page by providing relevant information?
   Suggestions:

    

    

3. How many links to graphics are on the page?
   
4. Do the links improve the content of the Web page?
   Suggestions:

    

    

5. Do all of the links work?
   

Form:

1. Compare the students' Web page with the Sample Page. Does it include all of the same components (parts) as the sample? (photo; titles with correct text size and style; Email links; Address and Date info. at end?
   
   Suggestions:

Overall Impressions:

What did you like most about the Web page? What are the one or two things about the Web page which need the most improvement?

Return to ESL 382 home page.

Created by: krauss@lclark.edu
Updated: 10/15/06